Forum Criticism Team Callsigns

All your draft are critique by us. εїз εїз εїз


Junior staff and some OS too!

NAME Chat Nick Callsign Image Crit Strengths Favorite things to review
BananaRepublicBananaRepublic Levi Eastern Tiger Swallowtail EasternTigerSwallowtail.jpg in-depth critique, plot holes, narrative, awkward wording long articles, heavy narrative, good drafts with large problems, train wreck articles
Captain KirbyCaptain Kirby CaptainKirby Question Mark QuestionMark.jpg Narratives, execution, computer science stuff and sentence flow/wording Short-medium length articles, articles that use a simple concept in a surprising way, and exploration logs
DrMagnusDrMagnus DrMagnus Red Admiral RedAdmiral.jpg Clinical Tone, Computer Science, Phrasing, Foundation Lore Anything involving Computers, CotBG, "Old School" articles
LadyKatieLadyKatie LadyKatie Cairns Birdwing CairnsBirdwing.jpg Tales, mechanics, grammar
LeveritasLeveritas Leveritas Crimson Spotted Forester CrimsonSpottedForester.jpg Line-by-line and concept, Clinical tone, humanoids, ideas for backstory, reasonable Containment Procedures. Ideas that are beautifully simple in their execution.
MendelssohnMendelssohn Mendelssohn Giant Owl GiantOwl.JPG Humanoids, characterization, evaluating if something can generate the intended emotional response in the reader, clinical tone, pacing, identifying extraneous info, general in-depth critique Character-focused drafts, shorter articles in general
Modern_ErasmusModern_Erasmus Modern_Erasmus Blue Morpho BlueMorpho.jpg Identifying superfluous info, narrative devolpment advice, grammar Anything related to history, mythology, or exploration
PedantiquePedantique Pedantique Summer Azure SummerAzure.jpg Line-by-line crit, conceptual/narrative review. General weirdness, medium to long in length.
PolynomPolynom Holly Blue HollyBlue.jpg awkward wording, grammar, and formatting mistakes; more line-by-lines than concept stuff prefer reviewing drafts from newer members, don't really have preference on length or general concept
ratsyratsy ratsy Orange Oakleaf OrangeOakleaf.jpg
RimpleRimple Rimple Comma Comma.jpg Theme, emotionality, character and dialogue. "Clinical tone". Helping newbies find direction & meaning in drafts. WEIRD SHIT
sirpuddingsirpudding sirpudding Snowberry Clearwing SnowberryClearwing2.JPG
Sly161Sly161 Sly161 Painted Lady PaintedLady.jpg Grammar/mechanics, knowing if an idea will work, Foundation lore. perfers short-medium length drafts, weird creatures/enviroments.
taylor_itkintaylor_itkin taylor_itkin, taylor_critkin, taylor, etc. Tailed Jay TailedJay.jpg Line-by-line, narrative, dialogue, character development, and brainstorming Shorter drafts, new-writer drafts, SCP articles, anything with "new" ideas
trettertretter tretter, trots Neglected Eighty-eight NeglectedEightyEight.JPG Concepts, narratives, logical consistency, sentence flow, artillery crit Train wreck drafts, drafts from people who don't know how to write at all/don't know the community or its expectations
Zachary MaxwellZachary Maxwell ZacharyMaxwell Peacock Peacock.jpg Line-by-line crit with additional honest focus on concept/narrative (or lack thereof) Drafts that are somewhat sinking but can be saved; medium to long drafts; drafts from people new to the site and new to the concept.


Other staff!

NAME Chat Nick Callsign Image
Doctor CimmerianDoctor Cimmerian Cimmerian (The Mighty) Monarch Monarch.jpg
Jacob ConwellJacob Conwell Conwell Oregon Swallowtail OregonSwallowtail.jpeg
Lazar LyusternikLazar Lyusternik Lazar Common Mormon CommonMormon.jpg
TaffetaTaffeta Taffeta Ulysses Swallowtail UlyssesSwallowtail.jpg
Tuomey TombstoneTuomey Tombstone Tuomey Emerald Swallowtail EmeraldSwallowtail.jpg
ZynZyn Zyn Queen Alexandra’s Birdwing Alexandra.jpg